Eb1a rfe major significance. Original contribution.
Eb1a rfe major significance ' This video breaks down three essential points: the importance of i Evidence of your authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major mediaThe purpose of this post is to provide tools that help you evaluate whether you could make an argument that you satisfy the 6th of the 10 EB-1A criteria, that you have evidence of your authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade • Original Contributions of Major Significance to the Field: The Policy Manual now states that evidence that the Beneficiary's work was funded, patented, or published is not enough on its own to demonstrate that the work is of major significance. Evidence of the alien's original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance in the field. How they benefit from your work and intend to continue using your contributions Articles about my work were published in major trade/industry publications. 来源 Evidence of the alien's original scientific, scholarly, artistic, or business-related contributions of major significance in the field: The record shows that the petitioner has provided several advisory opinion letters. immigration law firms providing the most comprehensive services for EB-1/ NIW petition with a large volume of approval cases and high approval rate. In our experience, critical role is an extremely difficult criterion to meet, and very few people meet the requirements for this criterion. Overview The Extraordinary Ability visa, also known as the EB-1A visa, is one of the most sought-after immigration routes to the United States. Whether you are a petitioner or the talent, you must have quality legal guidance throughout each step of the EB1A Visa process. This powerful step-by-step tool enriched with crucial tips, templates, and sample letters will lead you through the whole process from gathering the evidence to receiving your artist green card. I-140 (Standalone) I recently submitted an EB1A application and was issued an RFE in 2/3 categories. In some cases, a Request for Evidence (RFE) may be appropriate if an officer is not yet satisfied that the petitioner has met this requirement. Beyond academic citations, articles or studies that EB1A major media outlets have covered also Request For Evidence Requirement and RFE Response Requirement - detailed RFE response process, request for evidence requirements, samples of RFE response, and how to answer RFE requests from USCIS for his/her original contributions of major significance in the field. Boundless helps immigrants navigation the Visa application process more easily and with more confidence than ever before. I have received an RFE. EB1A RFE Status upvote Requesting to share experiences in an event of a RFE for EB1A. However, with the customized countermeasure designed by North America Immigration Law Group (NAILG), we seize every single chance and assist our clients to obtain case approval even under NSC jurisdiction. So withdrawing is jot an option at this 所以今天简单讲讲EB1A的Petition letter如何写作major contribution of significance. Any way, Hurry up and Good luck. 421 (1987). In the several I’ve seen through my friends, they’re rarely Extraordinary ability may be demonstrated through receipt of a one-time achievement of major significance (such as an Academy Award, Nobel Peace Prize, Grammy Award, Pulitzer, etc. Evidence of your original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field EB1A petitioners need to follow some requirements to obtain this visa. Remember, beyond meeting the three EB1A criteria, your evidence as a whole must demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim to qualify for EB1A. It’s an opportunity to provide the information required to get approved. I filled EB1A with premium processing (Nebraska) and got RFE after 12 days. It took my lawyer about 3 months to prepare my case. S. Supporting documents were mailed along with I-485 one week later. Do I need to have reached the highest position in my career to be eligible to apply in EB1A category? EB1A RFE response and chances of approval ; Applying for a green card ; long RFE (EB1A), please give some suggestion. If I had to explain it in one word — it boils down to “freedom”. ) or at least three of the following USCIS has announced a USCIS Policy Manual update, effective SEP 12, 2023, that clarifies the types of evidence that USCIS evaluates to determine eligibility for “extraordinary ability” (EB Basically, the USCIS Immigration Service Officers issue an RFE when they see an EB-1 petition is deficient in evidentiary support. All pieces of evidence submitted must answer the question of why your work is of major significance in the field. Unclear Details in Submitted EB1A Petition: If the USCIS adjudicator finds unclear aspects in your filed case, an RFE may be issued to seek clarification. Citations ~150, Reviews ~15, First Authors~5. My wife applied for a GC through the EB1A category, and we received a RFE. This criterion has not been met because the award does not appear to be a major, internationally recognized award. An approval notice means you have established your eligibility as an alien with extraordinary ability, and you and your You have reached top in the field by major contribution and belongs to small group of people in the field 5. Simply deny your application without an RFE or a NOID. How would I go about proving major significance? For additional context, originality was claimed You may be eligible for an employment-based, first-preference visa if you are a noncitizen of extraordinary ability, are an outstanding professor or researcher, or are a certain Nevertheless, you may have a lower chance of meeting the original contribution criteria, as it requires strong evidence to prove that your work is of major significance to the field. We are one of the leading U. Watch this thread Start a new thread Add a post . The RFE usually begins by quoting U. Both seemed (but correct me if I’m wrong) to be minor things — one related to high salary (wanted to see equity grants) and one related to scholarly publications (not enough charts and endnotes — what?!). Original contribution. I have been happy with the smooth process and the effective communication with my lawyer. I am working with Chen and they are suggesting that the officer is too strict to approve even the RFE response. The same RFE, questioned the major significance EB1A Nebraska RFE on Major significance and critical role . I am on EB1A. USA Employment Based Trackers EB1A RFE major significance . Victoria Chen, J. ) or at least three of the following ten criteria: (or “RFE”). Toggle navigation. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) is the government agency that oversees lawful immigration For example, USCIS can more easily review an RFE letter that simply needs a copy of a passport page than an RFE letter that needs many documents to prove a bona fide family relationship. Real-world applications of your work c. on demand who can review your case and write an expert opinion letter that could perhaps better explain the scientific significance of the client’s accomplishments. In this guide, I'm going to explain important details regarding the EB1A criteria and what USCIS To qualify for EB-1A, foreign nationals must provide evidence of “extraordinary ability” in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics. Over 1M Trackitt Users RFE in The EB-1A employment-based immigration visa can appear to be a daunting process. Does anyone have an example response? Main question on my mind is if I just need to address the specific concerns or do I need to resummarize all the information incorporating the added pieces of information? Evidence of major contributions to your field should highlight original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance. Remember, beyond Original contributions of major significance in the field: This is a key criterion, and you need to provide strong evidence of your original contributions. Over 1M Users on Trackitt . I-140 & I-485 (AOS) Hi all, like tge title says, I received RFE asking for Original scientific contributions. Toggle navigation EB1A . The letters must be written by experts in the field who have witnessed the alien’s professional development and have a deep understanding of the alien’s major Hi guys, I have received the rfe recently for my EB1 I 140 filed with TSC in PP. Contributions to the Field: Evidence of original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance. Evidence for this criterion includes publications, citations to the applicant’s published work, and letters from experts in the field. Over 1M Trackitt Users. or artistic contributions of major significance in the field of endeavor EB1A RFE EB-1A RFE’s (Request for Evidence) can be quite intimidating especially if you filed the petition yourself. Evidence PhD self-petition applicants in EB1a have to satisfy two-part evaluation for extraordinary ability in addition to 3 of 10 USCIS EB1A criteria. I-140 Application Timeline TLDR: The EB1a applicant (foreign worker) would have to satisfy (A) and (B) or (A) and (C), which means that the applicant must show they will continue to work in the same field of expertise after the issuance of the EB1a green card, and that they either have at least a one-time major internationally-recognized award or prize, or can show proof of their professional recognition Evidence of original contributions, usually through publication, of major significance in the foreign national’s fields of science, scholastic, artistic, or athletic: Recommendation letters from independent experts highlighting the foreign national’s significant contribution to his/her field of endeavor may be presented. You will need a third and according to your own description you are a bit soft on both 'contributions of major significance to the field' and 'nationally or international recognized awards'. Hi, did a self petition for eb1 with victoria chen. athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field; Here, you can submit testimony from leading professionals in your field. This could be in the form of EB1-A category is for individuals in the field of sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics. or business-related contributions of major Having patents can help you meet the EB1A criteria for original contributions, but only if you can demonstrate that your patents have had a major impact in your field. “Major Media” criterion: “Published material about the alien in professional or major trade publications or other major media relating to the alien’s work in the field for which classification is sought. Is an EB1A Green Card the fastest path to your American dream? For those with exceptional talent in fields like business, science, education, arts, or athletics, it can be. I used citation ranking and H index ranking to prove the major significance criterion and for the final merits determination. There may be an additional delay if an RFE is issued. ”[28] An individual’s findings may 1) how do you make a strong point for the part of Original Scientific Contributions of Major Significance? What I did in my initial petition was: explain my findings/achievements in projects I worked on, then use recommendation letters to further substantiate this point. The Law. Need an Urgent and well explained EOL draft Proving extraordinary ability for an EB1A green card application requires a combination of documentation and expert testimony. Submitted I-140 with Premium Processing (PP): 4 Aug 2021; I-140 approved: 11 Aug 2021; I-485 submitted: 24 Sept 2021; Biometrics: 4 Nov 2022; Medical RFE: 23 Dec 2021; EAD/AP Approved: 3 Feb 2022; I-485 Approved EB1A RFE upvote aiming to bring Reddit's attention to the significance of our concerns regarding the recently implemented API changes. Judging the Work of Others: Documentation showing participation as a judge of the work of others. The documentation and testimony should be support the claims you would like to make from the USCIS EB1A requirement list. I had a client who was a geologist and based on her assessment as to how much oil was in the cavity, the major oil company she worked for would decide 十万火急，跪求急问：EB1A 140 RFE . Media Coverage: Evidence of published material about your work in major media. Common Reasons for RFE (Request for Evidence) EB1A RFE: Asking for the circulation and the intended audience of the Published material and authorship of scholarly articles . We need help, as we don’t know exactly how to address this RFE. Got RFE within 2 weeks. Over 1M Users on You have submitted evidence of the alien's original scientific, scholarly, artistic or business-related contributions, but have not demonstrated that they are of major significance EB1A RFE - what now? either individually or on a panel, 2. IO XM1671 says i satisfied 2/3 criteria and needs more evidence for: Evidence of your original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field Seems like they think my work is original but are questioning if it National or international acclaim can be demonstrated by receipt of a major international award such as the Nobel prize or the Pulitzer. 26 reviews for major journa I140 EB1A NSC PP Major Original Contributions of Major Significance: This is a crucial criterion if your work has significantly impacted your field. Anyone received the rfe from this officer and got it ap. The short answer is yes—you can file for EB-1A Evidence of published material about you in professional or major trade publications or other major media; Evidence that you have been asked to judge the work of others, either individually or on a panel; Evidence of your original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field lol their rates vary with each client or i am just confused haha, i paid $3500 for NIW and was given the deal of 2 letters for $3000 for eb1a, i pushed them for four letters and got to pay $500 extra, my niw was without letters. Letters of support, patents, documentation that your work has been cited, and publications about the significance of your work can EB1A RFE: Asking for the circulation and the intended audience of the Published material and authorship of scholarly articles . If yours were published in big media (NYT, washington post etc) they generally wont ask, but depends on where yours published EB1A RFE: Asking for the circulation For example, contributions may have major significance if they represent a measurable increase to the current body of scholarship, as in the case of an insect researcher whose discovery of ninety‑six new species of jumping spiders represented “10% of the overall documented information regarding certain spider families. or business-related contributions of major GoEB1 aims to present the different criteria for EB1A in a series of blog posts. ----- Dear friends I received the RFE from TSC after PP, it pretty much listed all 10 criteria. Over 1M Trackitt Users Eb1A RFE TSC officer XM1583 . Responded and rest is in the timeline. Did not get any response. Our company is one of the 4 or 5 companies that develops a medical device that feeds people using robotic technology. Success Story: In Just 6 Months NIW Petition was Approved Despite Receiving an RFE, it achieved EB1A Approval 1 Month and 6 Days After Petition Submission with a Premium Processing Service Upgrade. Total citations-85; one publication has 60, the other two have 13 and 12. As you know, citation count is field-dependent. My . Read our extensive list of rules for more information on other types of posts like fan Hi all, My wife applied for EB1-A PP at Texas centre but she received an RFE on Sep 21st 2022. An applicant must either show proof of a one-time achievement (major EB1A is an immigrant visa category in the United States designated for individuals with extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics. Missing Documents: An RFE can be prompted by the absence of essential documents in your submission. Watch this thread Start a new thread Add a post Extraordinary ability may be demonstrated through receipt of a one-time achievement of major significance (such as an Academy Award, Nobel Peace Prize, Grammy Award, Pulitzer, etc. The petitioner submitted the following evidence:Media reports from Tech Bullion and MSN both published"A review of the material appears to establish that both articles are self-promoting Hi All, I have received RFE from Immigration Officer XM1317, TCS, in March 2021 for EB1A PP application. cottontail Registered Users (C) or business-related contributions of major significance in the field (They cannot be considered of major significance if there is only a perceived or anticipated benefit) (6) Evidence of alien's authorship of Evidence of your original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field This is one of the most mystic EB1A criteria, especially for those working in the cybersecurity space, and yet it is also one that many people can meet if they are truly on top of their field. Filed as PP to Texas Service Center using services from wegreened. a denial will be harder to challenge than say an RFE (Request For Evidence) for some criterias. However, with the customized countermeasure designed by North 收到 RFE for my EB1a，内容问得太仔细，让我几乎绝望。 of Science and Technology Promotion in Jiangsu Province of China any other documentary evidence to The EB1A is a green card visa for foreign nationals which falls under the employment-based immigration: first preference category (EB-1). This is supported by Relevance: Highlights how the applicant’s work matters in the industry, showing the significance of the individual’s work. For media houses, you use their online circulation if it was an online new media (you can get this circulation from websites like Semrush and similarweb Hi, I would be pleased if you could provide advice on my application petition on how to respond to an RFE. Used premium processing and got rfe. This seems really strange since my Hello, I received rfe on major significance on a eb1a submitted on June 2020. The failure to adequately consider the totality of the submission was arbitrary and capricious. we have 60 days to answer RFE. How they used your papers in product creation, publication, or revenue generation b. Make sure you respond to RFEs within the timeframe; otherwise, it may lead to the denial of your application. Read on to learn more about each of these parts of a USCIS request for evidence. It is EB1A Successful RFE Response Published Sep 13,2017 By Hariharan Ananth . , Esq. Artist Visa USA offers you the only DIY guide on the internet that is based on a petition of a visual artist. 4th was just published before petition submission. D in robotics and my specialization is consumer robotics (medical robotics). 99%的RFE都是针对Major contribution of Significance. According to USCIS, as the named Form I-140 beneficiary, you should submit the following documentation and evidence to apply as for an employment-based green card as an immigrant currently in the U. This is why impact and usage are so important to your EB-1 petition. This is the reality for those who successfully navigate the EB1A process. Relevance: Highlights how the applicant’s work matters in the industry, showing the significance of the individual’s work. Does anybody else received RFE from the same officer and succ. 4. Disclaimer: I am not an attorney but speak purely from my personal EB1A journey. A Postdoctoral Research Associate who EB-1A Green Card Process and Documentation. In October 2009, USCIS denied the EB-1A I-140 petition Hi, Friends, Today I got a really bad news on my EB1A PP at TSC. Thread starter cottontail; Start date Jun 25, 2006; C. You can also find the list and other details at this link. Professional publications; Critical role in field or profession; Comparable research position; High salary compared to comparable individuals in a similar role; Major significance in sciences, arts, education, business, athletics Explore a key EB-1A eligibility criterion: 'Original Contributions of Major Significance. to establish how and why the alien's work is considered original and how and why jt constitutes a contribution of major significance to the field of business compared to all others in the field A: To meet this criterion, the submitted evidence should show that the beneficiary’s contributions are considered to be of major significance in the field of endeavor. This blog will explore the EB1A processing time, the steps Such letters would play an important role for the RFE response also. An RFE contains four major parts: the law, a list of the evidence you submitted, a list of the evidence you are missing, and a response deadline. Need for Updated Information: USCIS might request updated Contributions of major significance suggest that the petitioner’s work has significantly impacted the field. Get Recommendation Letter for EB1A Original Contributions of Major Significance from Top rated Upwork Freelancer Brian O with 99% job success rate. But that's why you get a EB-1A lawyer to review your CV as others mentioned, and you can go from there. An applicant must either show proof of a one-time achievement (major I applied in 02/13 for EB1A - regular processing. I got a RFE saying I satisfy 2 of 3 criteria, but requests additional evidence for: original scientific scholarly contributions of major significance in the field. Case Summary: The Nebraska Service Center (NSC) has been particularly tough in its adjudications for EB1A. to establish how and why the alien's work is considered original and how and why jt constitutes a contribution of major significance to the field of business compared to all others in the field The EB-1A employment-based immigration visa can appear to be a daunting process. This blog will explore the EB1A processing time, the steps Finally, we at Chen Immigration Law Associates researched and cited applicable AAO (Administration Appeals Office) decisions regarding independent expert testimony and its use in establishing original contributions of major significance EB1A RFE . This content is not a substitute for legal advice. In general, It all depends on how good your lawyer's game is in fitting your career to the criterias for EB1A. You can still re-apply again! or business-related contributions of major significance to the field. I ranked my citation and H I just heard back with an RFE on my EB1A application that went to Nebraska. Learn more here. I was shocked to see that my EB1A was approved without an RFE just a day after requesting premium processing I got a RFE for my TSC EB1A (DIY, e-filed 5/2007. We have covered the judging criteria and the membership criteria in our past two posts. For her, the Expert Opinions are Recommendation Letters written to support the O-1 and EB-1A Visa criteria for “Original scientific, scholarly, or business-related contributions of major significance in the field”. 5%*. Contact an EB1A Attorney. Login Signup. Imagine the freedom of working, living, and traveling anywhere within the US, without visa restrictions. The significance of the prizes or awards, to include the national or international The EB-1A employment-based immigration visa can appear to be a daunting process. In addition, we also successfully helped around 70 clients preparing their RFE (Request for Evidence) responses that Customer: have applied for EB1A and I have got the following RFE for the criteriea - Published material in professional or trade publications or in major media publications about the beneficiary. Authorship of scholarly articles. Judging the Work of Others: Documentation showing participation as a judge of the work of Overview The Extraordinary Ability visa, also known as the EB-1A visa, is one of the most sought-after immigration routes to the United States. Citizenship and Immigration Services is issuing policy guidance in our Policy Manual to further clarify the types of evidence that we may evaluate to determine eligibility for I also got an RFE requesting objective evidence to satisfy the major significance criteria. This was from Texas though. Evidence of the foreign national’s authorship receiving a one-time achievement that is a major, internationally recognized award. scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field. See what evidence USCIS really looks for when it evaluates an EB1A petition. I believe that this helped in my approval. Support letters from colleagues, researchers, and government officials, describing: a. An RFE usually means that additional Original contributions of major significance in the field: This is a key criterion, and you need to provide strong evidence of your original contributions. Most cardiovascular research. Hi, I have a Ph. Evidence that you have been asked to judge the work of others, either individually or on a panel. They very much emphasize that you must prove that you have made a major impact. However, for the I-485, I had chosen to DIY because I know I-485 is much simpler than I-140 EB1A. athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field: Some of my projects were a fit the definition of this criteria Visas for EB1A are also current, which means that visas are immediately available for all nations in the first employment-based (EB-1) preference classification. I’ve qualified for 2 criteria and have an RFE on 2 others. 因为99. 6) Evidence of the alien's Understand the Exactly Meaning and Language in RFE Notice, and the Standard Outlined by USCIS in Requests For Evidence: Detailed Analysis of Two-Part Approach for EB1A Petition, Evidence Evaluation, Final Merits Determination, and RFE Notice Comprehensive Examinations for RFE Request of Major Prize or Award, and How to Reply It in Your EB1 A RFE at TSC. Read our extensive list of rules for more information on other types of posts like fan such as being a judge of the work of others, scientific contributions of major significance in the field, authorship of scholarly articles in the field. I would like to hear if replying to this would help. To assist in determining whether the beneficiary’s contributions are original and of major significance in the field, the petitioner may submit: receiving a one-time achievement that is a major, internationally recognized award. Aisha's Odyssey: A renowned biologist, Dr. all in 2023, profile is close to 1k citations, masters only no phd, 30+ papers, 80+ abstracts in the US. 1. also known as a “RFE” to allow you to strengthen the merits of your case The United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) uses a two-part approach to determining EB1A eligibility, meaning that after determining whether the individual has provided evidence of a major, internationally-recognized award or met at least three of the ten requisite criteria, USCIS must assess the EB1A petition in totality to determine whether the EB1A Original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance in the foreign national’s field . It is essential to provide adequate and specific evidence You have reached top in the field by major contribution and belongs to small group of people in the field 5. . The most wo Hello, Did anyone get RFE on EB1A TSC with officer code XM 1317? Over 1M Users on Trackitt . For media houses, you use their online circulation if it was an online new media (you can get this circulation from websites like Semrush and similarweb Accordingly, we claimed five criteria overall, and included within the petition evidence of the petitioner’s reception of a lesser-nationally recognized award, his participation as a judge of the work of others, the major media material published about the petitioner and his work, the petitioner’s scholarly articles which appeared in internationally-circulated trade The EB1A visa, a pathway to permanent residency in the United States, is specifically designed for individuals with extraordinary abilities across fields such as sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics. The major significance of his work was endorsed by an independent Specifically, we at North America Immigration Law Group have received 104 EB1A, EB1B, and NIW Approval Notices in with the approval rate exceeding 98. Trackers . As a result, a significant number of SGC VIP members successfully and legitimately construct their EB1A profiles within six months or even less. 6 It was clear that the USCIS had issued a boilerplate RFE and did not closely review the evidence submitted. I claimed 5 criteria: Published material about me Authorship of scholarly articles Original contributions of major significance Critical role in distinguished organization 139K subscribers in the USCIS community. officer code is XM1861. immigration law firms providing the most comprehensive services for EB-1/NIW petition with a large volume of approval cases and high approval rate. Timeline. I've seen PhDs with publication, review experience, and hundreds of citations got denied because the NSC officer challenged the original contribution of major significance criteria, citing their citation number is too low to meet this criteria. What makes it special? You can self-petition for EB1-A and not be tied to an However, in Feb 2020, I realized that I could self-petition even as a postdoc, as I published several scientific articles which had a total of 300+ citations (at that time), which was enough U. 27%. the publication is a major media or professional publication. Evidence of the foreign national’s authorship of scholarly articles which has major significance in proving that the person “is one of the small percentage who has risen to the very top” of the long RFE (EB1A), please give some suggestion. USCIS will provide you with a reason. Although the O-1 nonimmigrant visa category also requires “extraordinary Prior to an acceptance, there’s a reasonably high chance (~50% anecdotally) that you may get an RFE (Request for Evidence) or a NOID (Notice of Intent to Deny). The EB-1A Criteria Analysis - Alien's Original Scientific, Scholarly, Artistic, Athletic, or Business-Related Contributions of Major Significance in the Field To assist in determining whether the beneficiary’s contributions are original and of major significance in Evidence of published material about you in professional or major trade publications or other major media. RFE issued by USCIS for EB1A petition at times question the merit and national importance of the When responding to an RFE for an O-1 or EB-1 petition based on the “major national or international award” sole criterion, 12 do not respond with alternative evidence supporting several of the other enumerated criteria, as this weakens your case and validity of the sole criterion as a basis for the classification. In order to accentuate this client’s research to a select field and make sure no In the initial RFE, the USCIS officer (NSC #0317) acknowledged that sufficient evidence had been submitted to demonstrate that our client satisfied two of the three claimed criteria, but the Hi, My profile is as follows Filed EB1-A Nebraska in Premium Processing ( Self – Filing using your package / Filed NIW before 2 months ago to secure PD) Field – Aerospace The reason for expecting rfe is due to the fact that some officers might buy time if they have good work load and they see your application takes time to review. 1) how do you make a strong point for the part of Original Scientific Contributions of Major Significance? What I did in my initial petition was: explain my findings/achievements in projects I worked on, then use recommendation letters to further substantiate this point. original contributions of major significance; and 3) authorship of scholarly publications. This could be in the form of Hi I applied EB1A and they accepted 1. published material in major trade journal, the published material must show that your work is of major significnace ( we submitted 9 letters of support, from top tier scientist in my field) Original Contributions of Major Significance: Breakthrough research, innovations, or any other contributions that have fundamentally impacted a field can be highlighted here. e. The key lies in Original Contributions of Major Significance: This is a crucial criterion if your work has significantly impacted your field. Learn how leveraging high-impact publications can boost your EB1A visa application success. A Notice of Intend to Deny faxed to my Attorney this afternoon. Normally, the alien applicant should include three additional reference Original Contributions of Major Significance: Breakthrough research, innovations, or any other contributions that have fundamentally impacted a field can be highlighted here. Why your article is of major significance d. Essential tips for strong EB1A cases. An applicant must either show proof of a one-time achievement (major The best way to handle an RFE is to avoid getting one in the first place. Evidence of your authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media 3. Conclusion. Published Scholarly Articles Written by You: Evidence of your authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media. So, if you want to expedite your EB1A process, opt for premium processing. I am from chemistry and submitted 1200 citations (currently 1400) and got this rfe. Through the EB1A green card, you are eligible to self-petition. Receiving an RFE doesn’t In this case, it is likely that the criterion of “original contribution with major significance” be challenged. The RFE was for `Major significance`(most important criteria i g EB1-A PP RFE For Sep 2022 Original Contributions: Evidence of your original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance in the field. This could include pioneering research, innovative Evidence of original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field. 6. An applicant must either show proof of a one-time achievement (major Victoria Chen, J. Professional publications; Critical role in field or profession; If your publications are significant in the field and published in major journals, you may meet the EB1A criteria for authorship With fewer citations, you may not meet the EB1A criteria for The EB-1A employment-based immigration visa can appear to be a daunting process. It typically refers to a request made by the USCIS for a #EB1A #RFE on Media/Major Trade/Major Professional Publications about Applicant meaning there were no waiting periods for visa issuance. For her, the What is a Request for Evidence (RFE)? USCIS issues an RFE when they believe they don’t possess enough information to make a decision on your case. It allows these individuals to self-petition for a green card without needing a job offer or labor certification. 25% for "Approval or Refund ®" (money back guarantee) service and the overall approval rate for all EB1A cases is 95. v. Like this thread 0 0. Common Reasons for an EB1A RFE. original scientific, scholarly, (etc) contributions of major significance in the field (vi) authorship of scholarly articles in the I just heard back with an RFE on my EB1A application that went to Nebraska. A well-written Expert Opinion Letter can make a big difference in the EB1A application by providing a clear evaluation that matches EB1A requirements. Receiving an RFE doesn’t mean your application is denied. ) or at least three of the following I received an RFE on my EB1A I140 petition at TSC on major significance criteria. EB1a with three claims: judge others works, major significance of contributions, authorship of scholarly articles. An applicant must either show proof of a one-time achievement (major This is a common question, especially among those who meet the criteria of original contributions of major significance, a high salary, and leading or critical roles within their organizations. 很多trivial的讲解网上到处可见，我只讲深层次的思路构建。 整体思路. Here's what you need to know about a Request for Evidence (RFE) from the U. Evidence of your authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media. And, coming to an understanding that having freedom in this country didn’t necessarily mean shutting Extraordinary ability may be demonstrated through receipt of a one-time achievement of major significance (such as an Academy Award, Nobel Peace Prize, Grammy Award, Pulitzer, etc. How come only 6 days. I was aksed to provide everything . This criteria becomes much harder at the point in the petition where the USCIS officer considers if your contributions are of “major significance”. (From our experience, such RFEs have been the trend for Premium Processing EB-1As). The other RFE was medical. I understand what the IO is looking for, and I know how to highlight my strengths in my petition letter even though my citation record is weak. U. I helped the innovators build the prototype while i was Major trade publications; Scholarly research contributions, such as scholarly articles, scholarly journals, etc. This means that you can apply for yourself without an employer sponsoring you. The RFE challenged two criteria: original contributions of major significance as well as critical role in a distinguished organization. EB1A RFE Status EB1A RFE . did u withdraw or respond to RFE , what was the outcome? I feel it does not sounds like too tough. The EB-1A employment-based immigration visa can appear to be a daunting process. Hello friends, I’d written up a EB1A application without a lawyer. Having patents can help you meet the EB1A criteria for original contributions, but only if you can demonstrate that your patents have had a major impact in your field. I have a Ph. For EB1A cases, the approval rate is 97. This was due to spillovers (unused visas) from family Media Coverage: Evidence of published material about your work in major media. It states that, [] Responding to an RFE. I got an RFE on the I-140 on June 28, 2023 with 90 days to respond. I am from chemistry and submitted 1200 citations (currently 1400) and got this rfe I have read through hundreds of EB1A materials, reviewed other people’s applications, studied their EB1A stories, and analyzed EB1A RFE templates. RFE issued by USCIS for EB1A petition at times question the merit and national importance of the A Scientist II from India, who has made original contributions of major significance to the field of synthetic organic chemistry, focusing on the synthesis and purification of oligonucleotides and has already greatly advanced the national interest by providing groundbreaking improvements in protocols and processes for organic chemical synthesis. Watch this thread Start a new thread Add a post Questions about RFE for EB1A Published Nov 2,2016 By Marcelo . Toggle navigation EB1A PP Texas service center I140 RFE . (RFE) notice. RFE issued by USCIS for EB1A petition at times question the merit and national importance of the Evidence of your original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic or business-related contributions of major significance to the field. ” EB-1 categories have consistently had a very high standard of law, especially EB1A Alien of Extraordinary Ability and therefore we at Chen Whether considered in a Part I analysis or as part of a Part II final merits determination, the AAO’s evaluation of what makes an “original contribution” rise to the level of “major significance” is the same, with the AAO heavily weighing evidence that petitioner’s findings “have affected the field in a major way, that his research has been widely utilized or heavily cited, or excessively focused on the significance of individual components of the submission. with good publications and citation records. I found that the NOID actually requests evidence of everything, exactly like the general RFE my colleagues received (also EB1A @ TSC), but it is called Intent to Deny and, instead of 12 weeks, it only gives 30 days to respond. : Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status;; Form I-797, Approval or Receipt Notice, for EB1A RFE Status . The foreign national must satisfy all of these elements to meet this evidentiary criterion. It is Evidence of published material about you in professional or major trade publications or other major media; Evidence that you have been asked to judge the work of others, either Case Summary: The Nebraska Service Center (NSC) has been particularly tough in its adjudications for EB1A. cottontail Registered Users (C) or business-related contributions of major significance in the field (They cannot be considered of major significance if there is only a perceived or anticipated benefit) (6) Evidence of alien's authorship of Evidence of published material about you in professional or major trade publications or other major mediaThe purpose of this post is to provide tools that help you evaluate whether you could make an argument that you satisfy the 3rd of the 10 EB-1A criteria, that material has been published about you in professional or major trade publications or other Support letters from colleagues, researchers, and government officials, describing: a. The regulations describe various types of evidence that the petitioner must submit I got an RFE which asks me to prove that the original contribution is of major significance. Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers. Once CIS receives the RFE response, it 5. The EB1A is a green card visa for foreign nationals which falls under the employment-based immigration: first preference category (EB-1). Scholarly Articles 2. It all depends on how good your lawyer's game is in fitting your career to the criterias for EB1A. Common Reasons for RFE (Request for Evidence) The EB1A visa, a pathway to permanent residency in the United States, is specifically designed for individuals with extraordinary abilities across fields such as sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics. Your reco letters must clearly mention the significance of your published papers and the profile of the journal . patents, licenses, inventions, trademarks, etc. Request for Evidence (RFE) fo EB1 Extraordinary Ability, EB1 Outstanding Professor or Researcher, EB2 National Interest Waiver - Request For Evidence Questions and Answers - detailed outstanding researcher RFE response process for EB1 and NIW, request for evidence requirements for EB1 andf NIW, EB2 National Interest Waiver petition, and how to answer Hi Guys, I am planning to do a self-petition for EB1A. immigration law. It has to be clearly above and beyond what most scientist achieve 6. Initial Steps Upon Receiving an RFE. 5 U. I-140 (Standalone) The goal of /r/Movies is to provide an inclusive place for discussions and news about films with major releases. Don’t panic. This criterion has not been met because the award does not appear to be a major, internationally Considering this client had received an RFE EB1a cases traditionally require a large number of citations in order to establish the influence of the client’s work. I am planning to provide my response to this offi EB1A PP RFE TCS Officer XM1317, Molecular Cell Biology, Post-doctoral Research Associate . IO 0024 says I fulfill 2 criteria (Evidence of authorship, and Judge of the work of others). Having major media Learn about the EB1A criteria. 9 first author. The 160-page guide includes every single detail we learned during two years of A denial or request of evidence(RFE) is not the end of your immigration dreams. a denial will be harder to challenge than say an RFE (Request For Evidence) for some What is a Request for Evidence (RFE)? USCIS issues an RFE when they believe they don’t possess enough information to make a decision on your case. ), among other evidence required by the EB-1 regulatory criteria, the organizations or establishments would qualify as ones with Prior to an acceptance, there’s a reasonably high chance (~50% anecdotally) that you may get an RFE (Request for Evidence) or a NOID scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance in the field; Scholarly Articles — The person’s authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or Based on my experience, here are some common reasons USCIS might issue an RFE for an EB-1A petition: Insufficient evidence of sustained national or international acclaim; Lack of clarity on how your contributions are of major significance in your field; Questions about the prestige of your awards or the exclusivity of your memberships Respond to the RFE. An applicant must either show proof of a one-time Delve into essential EB1A requirements for securing a Green Card and actualize your American dream with our EB1A Roadmap. Your publications and referees may be enough, not enough information at the moment. I have submitted For instance, if the organizations or establishments have similar evidence of nationally-acclaimed awards, major media coverage, and original contributions of major significance (i. Evidence of the aliens original contributions of major significance to the field. This could include pioneering research, innovative projects, or advancements that have changed your field’s operations. So I upgraded it to premium processing on 01/14. How they benefit from your work and intend to continue using your contributions Hi I applied EB1A and they accepted 1. r/AskCarSales will remain private Sunday, 06/11 through Wednesday, 06/14 r/Save3rdPartyApps PLEASE DO NOT MESSAGE US Here’s why I did it. Media (don't think this w. We originally applied for the following 5 criteria. Maybe that’s why it didn’t display. If yours were published in big media (NYT, washington post etc) they generally wont ask, but depends on where yours published EB1A RFE: Asking for the circulation The EB-1A employment-based immigration visa can appear to be a daunting process. An applicant must either show proof of a one-time achievement (major Articles about my work were published in major trade/industry publications. or business-related contributions of major significance to the field: (RFE). The best evidence often includes recommendation letters from independent experts who can discuss your achievements and their significance in the field. For example, the letters from professionals in the field In a recent RFE, USCIS had confused the job title . (1)To provide the selection criteria for a reviewer. Like all USCIS forms, RFE stands for "Request for Evidence," which is a common occurrence in the EB1A application process. × Please submit your thread title NSC officers are generally tough to deal with. Original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic or business-related contributions of major significance in the field of endeavor; Authorship of scholarly articles in the field, published in professional or major trade publications or major media; Display of the foreign national’s work at artistic exhibitions or showcases Each EB1A application is adjudicated on its own merits, regardless of whether premium processing is chosen. However a successful petition is not solely dependent on support letters. Regarding patents, the Policy Manual indicates that while granted patents may be evidence of an “original” contribution, they are not Delve into essential EB1A requirements for securing a Green Card and actualize your American dream with our EB1A Roadmap. Perhaps your petition is not well written or it’s a BS RFE to buy time. decisions regarding This is a common question, especially among those who meet the criteria of original contributions of major significance, a high salary, and leading or critical roles within In the event, USCIS issues a Request for Evidence (RFE) concerning I-485 Adjustment of Status, our attorneys will craft a response in a timely manner to fight for the approval of your I-485 Major trade publications; Scholarly research contributions, such as scholarly articles, scholarly journals, etc. To know it’s a BS RFE, the RFE won’t provide specific reasons why a specific evidence fails to meet the criteria. ” EB-1 categories have consistently had a very high standard of law, especially EB1A Alien of Extraordinary Ability and therefore we at Chen The crux of the EB1A petition largely hinges on meeting the "original contributions of major significance" criterion; in our experience, most EB1A RFEs we encounter challenge this particular element of the EB1A legal standard. My credentials: 4 publications-3 first authored. I claimed 3 and two ar. 1030 Citation. My EB1A got approved by USCIS within 10 days with premium processing service. EB1A RFE . Load all objective evidences so I just got EB1A denied. Media (don't think this w hi, Someuser1 , I would really appreciate your help in this matter-- filed eb1a Tsc, second time PP , xm1852 issed rfe - major significance not satisfied. Applicants must demonstrate that they are recognized as among National or international acclaim can be demonstrated by receipt of a major international award such as the Nobel prize or the Pulitzer. Receipts for both received within two weeks). The publication details were available online and its targeted to industry and technologies I work in. Dr. This category allows these individuals to obtain a green card (permanent residency) without the need for a labor certification or a specific job offer, as long as they continue to work in their field of expertise. Hello. Citizenship and Immigration Services office (USCIS). We are currently in AOS (concurrent filing) and working only due to EAD. An applicant must either show proof of a one-time achievement (major National or international acclaim can be demonstrated by receipt of a major international award such as the Nobel prize or the Pulitzer. Cardozo-Fonseca, 480 U. I just got the RFE for my EB1A (EA). I had applied via PP. I am surprised EB1A greencard will take that long Hello, I received rfe on major significance on a eb1a submitted on June 2020. Aisha, despite her numerous accolades, faced an RFE (Request for Evidence) during her EB1A application. In both cases, assume the former and respond with a However, the criteria is lower with EB2-NIW, so if you don’t satisfy the EB1A criteria, you will have to do that anyway. widely cited papers, and articles in major media outlets carry more weight than numerous publications with little recognition For example, if you have made original contributions of major significance to your The SGC program addresses the challenges you may encounter on the EB1A path and offers ethical assistance in all aspects of EB1A profile development. Posted by wegreened on March 11, and objective evidence that her original contributions are of major significance. Their standard for an EB1A case is extremely high. 2. Among the thirty-nine AAO decisions reviewed, twenty-four Evidence of your original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field Evidence that you have been asked to judge the work of Hi i have received a RFE from TSC officer XM1583 on my EB1A I-140 petition for major significance. However, IO says I didn't Hello, Did anyone get RFE on EB1A TSC with officer code XM 1317? Over 1M Users on Trackitt . Judge work of others but need more evidence for 3. D. or business-related contributions of major Nothing to great but believed I submitted a decent EB1A petition: 15 publications. major contribution of significance不光要将你的研究如何重要，更重要的是 EB1A-RFE from TSC please help. Have not received any details yet. xdakyyvyuhcwuuoswoeogoijshuduidjimdatsjmuiwghzdstecpp